5 Arguments Against “Is That REALLY How You Saw It?” – #4: Are You (Color) Blind?!Posted by drfl on June 8th, 2010
We all see color differently. For instance, it has been researched that men in general cannot see shades of yellow as well as women in general. Men are also more often to be color blind. I had a friend in college that was extremely color blind. One day in one of his classes a clever college professor decided to change his chalk color choice. He began writing with pink chalk on a green chalkboard. Unfortunately for my friend, he was unable to take notes that day as the pink words blended into the green background.
To become a little more philosophical, I pose a simple question. What if the colors that you know are not the colors others know? For example, let’s say that when you were born you intrepet the color “red” really as “green”. As you go through life, people tell you that it’s “green”, you read books about “green”, you get conditioned know what “green” is, but you see what everyone else sees as “red”. You would see “red” and call it “green” and everyone would agree because they have been conditioned to see it as “green”. What if someone saw “blue” and had been conditioned to see it as “green”? It’s really a matter of perspective. Since we cannot leave our bodies and get into someone else’s we have no real validation that the colors we interpret is anyway the same as anyone else. If one can wrap your mind around an esoteric concept such as this, one would begin to realize that the color world that we interpret may not really be the colors we think they are. They are simply the colors that we have been conditioned to believe.
The point here is that if one captures a photograph, there is no guarantee that the colors will be anything that anyone else has experienced. To continue this line of reasoning, when I produce a black and white photograph, I have never had anyone ask me if the image is “authentic”. Simple, black and white photography has garnered a reputation of being artistic so people accept it as such. Why can’t color photography enjoy the same benefit? Gary Uelsmann is a well known black and white artist who combines images from different sources into a single, unrealistic image, and he has been doing it for years and all without Photoshop. I doubt many complain that his images do are not what he really “saw”.
To this end, by the very nature of color photography, the colors will never be what you experienced from a technical standpoint. Our brains intrepet colors from the rays of light that enter our eyes. We may try hard to replicate those same colors in the darkroom, but we will never be 100%, nor should we be. Color can denote various emotions, warmth, cold, and when used in this fashion helps to shape the composition before us. Even a lack of color creates a “feeling” in the composition. To this end, the question “Is that REALLY how you saw it?” is moot.
Mass Believability? – 8 Those colors look a little off too me!
Technical Details:
Canon G10, 6.1mm, f/2.8
Gateway Arch, Jefferson National Expansion Memorial, St. Louis, Missouri










